1Census: Winning, Israel and Malinda (Castle), 1850 (Ohio, Champaign Co., Union Twp. - 12 Oct 1850, P293 L3). "Winning, Israil (M 35, farmer, VA); Malinda (F 35 VA); Elizabeth J. (F 14 VA); Anne M. (F 13 VA); Matilda (F 9 OH); Rebecca (F 6 OH); Samuel B. (M 2 OH).".
2Census: Winning, Malinda (Castle),1860 (Ohio, Champaign Co., Union Twp., Mutual PO - 20 July 1860, P106 L10). "Winning, Malinda (F 46 VA); Rebecca (F 18 OH); Samuel (M 12 OH); Martha (F 8 OH).".
3Census: Winning, Malinda (Castle), 1870 (Ohio, Champaign Co., Union Twp., Urbana PO - 6 August 1870, P24 L3). "Craig, Van (M 50, farmer, no write, VA); Elizabeth (F 36, keeping house, no write, VA); Rhoda (F 16, school, OH); Lavinia (F 14, school, OH); Perry (M 12, school, OH); Dilla (M? 11, school, OH); Winning, Malinda (F 65, invalid, no read/write, VA)." * Malinda is the mother of Elizabeth Craig.
1Census: Winning, Israel and Malinda (Castle), 1850 (Ohio, Champaign Co., Union Twp. - 12 Oct 1850, P293 L3). "Winning, Israil (M 35, farmer, VA); Malinda (F 35 VA); Elizabeth J. (F 14 VA); Anne M. (F 13 VA); Matilda (F 9 OH); Rebecca (F 6 OH); Samuel B. (M 2 OH).".